ERB's stories were often changed for strip adaptation for religious
reasons. UFS felt that "the religious sensibilites of newspaper readers
are easily offended." The adaptation of Tarzan Triumphant
was so extensively revised that it appeared to be an entirely new story,
in fact, they even changed the title to Tarzan and the Fire Gods.
Robert Barrett in his Tarzan of the Funnies (2002 - House of
Greystoke Publication - Mad Kings Publishing) stated:
"Their reasons for this drastic revision was to eliminate the use of
early Christians as the forgotten people, for fear that religious persons
might consider it a burlesque of their beliefs. . . "
The Syndicate made even more drastic changes in ERB's plot: ". . . to
eliminate the Russian plot as a menace, since this had become another controversial
subject; and to supply the remaining characters and situations with new
and logical activation."
"After reading the synopsis and the first few continuities Ed sarcastically
commented that 'it is apparent that you folks have gone Hollywood; that
if it is necessary to change the story as much as you have, the title must
also be chabnged as well as the names of all the characters because . .
. unless this is done it might affect the sale if the novel Tarzan
Triumphant.' Ed could not understand why UFS would be afraid to
take exception to the Red Menace. . . . "
"William Laas, UFS Business manager, in his reply to Ed, noted that
'it has been our experience that newspapers violently object to any treatment
of religion in strip form unless the attack be purely reverent. On the
other hand, the second consideration, Red menace, was the result of our
experience with Tarzan the Untamed and Tarzan the Invincible.
These are two of the continuities which contained the Red Menace. It was
our experience with both of these that editors requested us to eliminatf
whole weeks of these sequences involving the Red Menace. Their objection
was not so much ot the Reds themselves as to the fact that the Reds no
longer are considered the menace they were when this book was written.
In a changing world, I am sure you will appreciate that just as the word
"Hun" has come to mean so little, the word "Red" has been deprived of some
of its worse aspects.' After receiving a list of five suggested titles
for the new continuity, Ed chose Tarzan and the Fire Gods.
In response to later changes made to his stories, Ed replied caustically:
"I see no advantage in the changes they have made, but let it pass if they
wish to make them. We have learned from long experience that anyone can
write a better Tarzan story than I." Another noteworthy observation made
by ERB: "I read the outline. Personally, I think you've spoiled the story;
but what's the use? Motion picture producers, newspaper syndicates, and
God have a corner on all knowledge. The rest of us don't know nuthin'."